Martha Plimpton's Brooklyn Victorian Home Sold for $2.6 Million
Emmy-winning actress Martha Plimpton recently concluded a significant chapter in her life by selling her cherished Victorian residence in Brooklyn's vibrant Prospect Lefferts Gardens neighborhood. After twelve years of ownership and extensive renovations, the historic property, which Plimpton affectionately dubbed 'The Martha Plimpton House for Wayward Women and Divorcées,' officially changed hands for an impressive $2.65 million. This sale marks a substantial increase from her initial purchase price in 2013 and coincides with her move to London, leaving behind a home rich with personal memories and a strong connection to the local community.
Celebrated Actress Martha Plimpton Sells Beloved Brooklyn Victorian for $2.6 Million
In a notable real estate transaction, on January 9, 2026, acclaimed actress Martha Plimpton, known for her roles in films like The Goonies and television series such as The Good Wife, finalized the sale of her Brooklyn Victorian home. Located in the picturesque Prospect Lefferts Gardens area of Flatbush, this residence served as Plimpton's sanctuary for over a decade. She acquired the property in spring 2013, undertaking a comprehensive gut renovation that transformed it into a personal haven. The final sale price of $2.65 million represents a substantial gain of approximately $1.3 million over her original investment.
The distinguished white wood-sided Victorian, originally constructed in the early 1900s, welcomes visitors with an inviting front porch framed by elegant Corinthian columns. Spanning approximately 2,800 square feet across three levels, the interior boasts four bedrooms and five bathrooms. Throughout the home, residents and guests are treated to the timeless beauty of hardwood floors, soaring high ceilings, and intricate decorative moldings. A finished basement provides additional functional space.
The main floor is an entertainer's dream, featuring a gracious living room with a wood-burning fireplace and custom built-in bookshelves. A formal dining room seamlessly extends to an outdoor dining deck, offering views of a meticulously cultivated garden below, flourishing with fruit trees, vegetables, and roses. The heart of the home, an all-white kitchen, is equipped with a six-burner Ilve gas range, a grill, premium Miele and Sub-Zero appliances, luxurious marble countertops, a classic porcelain farmhouse sink, and a butcher block-topped eat-in island, where Plimpton famously prepared Bolognese sauce using tomatoes from her backyard.
The second floor houses three generously sized bedrooms. One features a wall of cedar closets and a lavish marble bathroom complete with radiant-heated floors, dual sinks, and a charming clawfoot tub. A second bedroom enjoys a bay window, while the third includes a built-in desk and a windowed closet, both sharing a hallway bathroom equipped with a steam shower. The uppermost level of the home is dedicated to a spacious, light-filled primary suite, offering versatility for use as a playroom or studio. The basement further enhances the home's functionality with a dedicated laundry room and a convenient half-bath.
The sale, facilitated by Pamela D’Arc of Compass, marks a new chapter for Plimpton as she transitions to life in London. Her former home not only stands as a testament to her personal style but also as a significant piece of Brooklyn's real estate landscape.
Martha Plimpton's decision to sell her Brooklyn home and relocate to London highlights the dynamic nature of celebrity real estate and the personal journeys that often accompany such moves. Her appreciation for the diverse and close-knit community of Prospect Lefferts Gardens, a stark contrast to more 'twee' neighborhoods, offers a refreshing perspective on urban living. The substantial profit from her home's sale underscores the enduring value of well-maintained, historically significant properties in sought-after locations. Moreover, the detailed description of her home life, from cooking with a beloved cookbook to hosting guests in 'The Martha Plimpton House for Wayward Women and Divorcées,' paints a vivid picture of a celebrity who valued comfort, community, and personal expression in her living space. It reminds us that behind the public persona, there are personal stories and choices that shape our lives and homes.